(Barter Theatre 1440) 2005
As the CD title says... this is a recording from the "Man Of Constant Sorrow" play about the Stanley Brothers, that was premiered at the Barter Theatre in Abingdon, Va on 25th Aug 2005 and had a grand opening on the 28th, when Ralph and family attended.[1] It is a fictionalised account, rather than 100% historically accurate, and Ralph later commented: "... they played me pretty dumb in that play, made me more backwards than I ever was. The writers told me they done that to sell more tickets, and I can understand it, because in a play you can make your story any way you want. It was a good play, I enjoyed it, but it really wasn't me up on that stage".[2]
Ralph must have thought the play was ok though, as he added an additional day to his 'Hills Of Home' festival, just so the play could be performed there in 2006.[3]
As cover versions / imitations / tributes go, the CD is enjoyable. It's best listened to in conjunction with reading the liner notes, as they give an overview of the play, putting the musical sequence into context. Sections of the spoken word link the songs together in places, and the recording was made live with the cast going through the show as they did on stage.
In a way it's a shame that all of the dialogue couldn't be included (which would have required a 2xCD set), but you can still get the gist of what's going on, especially if you've read some of the books about Ralph and the Stanley Brothers.
The "CMB" line-up musician's included in the cast were:-
Also featured are: Amelia Ampuero as Ralph's wife Jimmie Stanley (nee Crabtree); and Kimberley Mays as Ralph & Carter's mother Lucy Stanley. In addition to their roles in the band, Ed Snodderly also plays Syd Nathan (King label boss) and Orderley / Bus Driver; Buddy Woodward likewise doubles as the preacher and WCYB Station Manager.
PS: It looks like Ralph missed an opportunity to get some publicity on this one for his 'Stanleytone' banjos... Gill Braswell uses a Gold Tone 250-AT arch top...
Track: |
Title: |
Time: |
Date: |
Original Release: |
|||||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Act I |
|
|
|
|
|||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-1 |
Man Of Constant Sorrow |
02:30 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
R.D. Burnett |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-2 |
How Mountain Girls Can Love |
01:52 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
Ruby Rakes |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-3 |
"The Preacher's Introduction" |
00:36 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
N/A |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-4 |
Amazing Grace |
01:35 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
John Newton |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-5 |
Finger Poppin' Time |
01:34 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
Hank Ballard |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-6 |
The Fields Have Turned Brown |
02:45 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
C. Stanley |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-7 |
Little Maggie |
02:01 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
P.D. |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-8 |
Precious Memories |
00:33 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
Johnnie Wright |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-9 |
Shout Little Lulie / White Dove |
03:09 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
P.D. / C. Stanley |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-10 |
WCYB Radio Theme Song |
00:13 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
?? |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-11 |
"A Pig and a Banjo" |
00:28 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
N/A |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-12 |
Pig In A Pen |
01:26 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
P.D. or Arthur Smith? |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-13 |
O Death |
02:14 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
P.D. |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-14 |
Drifting Too Far From The Shore |
00:24 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
Charles E. Moody |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-15 |
Harbor Of Love |
02:36 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
C. Stanley |
|||||||||||||||||||||
Act II |
|
|
|
|
|||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-16 |
The Old Home |
02:03 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
C. Stanley |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-17 |
"Carter's Dream" |
00:41 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
N/A |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-18 |
Rank Stranger |
03:11 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
Albert E. Brumley |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-19 |
Shouting On The Hills Of Glory / I Only Exist |
02:17 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
E.M. Bartlett - Joyce Morris / Jimmie Stanley |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-20 |
I Only Exist |
02:54 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
Joyce Morris / Jimmie Stanley |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-21 |
I'll Fly Away |
01:46 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
Albert E. Brumley |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-22 |
Mountain Dew |
02:09 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
Bascom Lamar Lunsford / Scotty Wiseman |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-23 |
"Carter speaks" |
00:36 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
N/A |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-24 |
Let Me Rest |
02:11 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
R. Stanley / C. Stanley |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-25 |
Angel Band |
03:28 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
Jefferson Hascall / William B. Bradbury |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-26 |
Mary, Merry Christmas |
01:54 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
C. Stanley |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-27 |
"Ralph remembers Carter" |
00:24 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
N/A |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-28 |
Gloryland |
01:16 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
P.D. |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-29 |
Clinch Mountain Backstep |
01:31 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
Ruby Rakes |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-30 |
God Gave You To Me |
01:15 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
R. Stanley |
|||||||||||||||||||||
A-31 |
Man Of Constant Sorrow |
01:23 |
2005 |
Barter Theatre Presents... |
|||||||||||||||||
R.D. Burnett |
[1] The source for this is now defunct: http://www.cmt.com/news/1508303/stanley-brothers-play-opening-in-virginia/
[2] Ralph Stanley and Eddie Dean's book "Man Of Constant Sorrow" (p.13)
[3] The 'General Store' section of the April 2006 edition of 'Bluegrass Unlimited' reporteed that Ralph added an extra day so that the play could be performed at his festival on 24th May 2006. (p. 12)