Clinch Mountain Echo

CMB Birthdays this month:

04 May 1922 - Harold 'Red' Stanley. Born 'Harold Oplis Stanley' in Fentress, Tennessee.

18 May 1938 - Henry Dockery. Walnut Marsh, North Carolina.

28 May 1956 - Ralph 'Hank' Smith. Born 'Ralph Dewayne Smith' in Elliott County, Kentucky.


In Memoriam:

02 May 1974 - Roy Lee Centers. Breathitt County, Kentucky.

03 May 2000 - Bill Napier. Johnson City, Tennessee.

09 May 1989 - Keith Whitley. Goodlettsville, Davidson County, Tennessee.

23 May 2022 - James Price. Parkersburg, Wood, West Virginia.


For the Official Ralph Stanley II and the Clinch Mountain Boys site, visit:

Ralph II ralph2.com

Spotlight on:-

Doctor's Orders: A Tribute to Ralph Stanley
(Rebel REB-CD-1841)


CME Recommends...

A Life Of Constant Sorrow
alifeofsorrow.com

CME Recommends...

Ralph Stanley Museum
ralphstanleymuseum.com

CME Recommends...

Hills Of Home Festival
drralphstanleyfestival.com

CME Recommends...

Rebel Records
rebelrecords.com

CME Recommends...

Bluegrass Unlimited
Bluegrass Unlimited
Clinch Mountain Echo

The Goins Brothers - Bluegrass Country

(Jalyn JLP-131) 1971


Bluegrass Country

Average Album Rating: 4
(Total votes 2)

  • 5 star
  • 4 star
  • 3 star
  • 2 star
  • 1 star

Please rate this album:

The second LP by the Goins Brothers was recorded on 10th May 1970. One 45 from the session was released shortly afterwards:- Fly Little Bluebird / Pistol Packin' Mama (Jalyn 45 353) 1970, but the LP didn't see light of day until a year later in mid-1971.

Musically the album is more country orientated than it's predecessor, and although it garnered quite a reasonable review in the Sept 1971 issue of 'Bluegrass Unlimited', it's said to have received some criticism in some quarters for the lack of any mandolin or fiddle.

Featured on the album are Dave Sutherland on bass and Harley Gabbard on Dobro. Dave Sutherland had previously played with Jim & Jesse whilst Harley Gabbard, from New Trenton Indiana, had played with Hylo Brown, Jim McCall and the Osborne Brothers. He also later helped form The Boys From Indiana, recording ten albums with them between 1975 and 1989.

Harley Gabbard sings lead on three cuts: This Train Is Going To Nashville, which he also wrote; the old train disaster song Wreck Of The Old '97; and the Carl Perkins' Daddy Sang Bass. The latter was a hit for Johnny Cash, and Harley has a somewhat similar vocal style on both that and This Train Is Going To Nashville.

On the bluegrass front, there's still plenty on offer, but there's only two original tunes: Fly Little Bluebird, a slow lamenting waltz which is co-credited to Mike Paxton (a DJ for WLSI in Pikeville Ky); and the banjo/dobro instrumental Chief Sitting Bull.

Of the non-original material: Pistol Packin' Mama is an fast-paced version of the 1943 honky tonk hit; Salty Dog Blues and Gone Home are patterned after Flatt & Scruggs. There's also three re-recordings of material Ray and Melvin had previously cut with the Lonesome Pine Fiddlers: Windy Mountain, Why Do You Treat Me The Way That You Do? & Lonesome Pine.

One track from the recording session, a sprawling & non too successful comedy arrangement of George Jones White Lightning with Dave Sutherland imitating Country stars, was omitted from the original LP. It was however included in the 1981 reissue. The reissue with the black sleeve had a different front cover picture and on the rear some copies had stickers over Jack Lynch's address.

Four cuts from the album were later re-recorded by The Goins Brothers:-

  • Melvin Goins: guitar, vocals
  • Ray Goins: banjo, vocals
  • Harley Gabbard: dobro, vocals
  • Dave Sutherland: bass

 

Track:
Title:
Time:
Date:
Original Release:
A-1
This Train Is Going To Nashville
01:59
10 May 1970
Bluegrass Country

Harley Gabbard
  Hr Vcl / Gtr Hr Vcl / Bjo Ld Vcl / Dobro Bs      
  Melvin Goins
Ray Goins
Harley Gabbard
Dave Sutherland
 
   
A-2
Salty Dog Blues
01:50
10 May 1970
Bluegrass Country

Wiley Morris / Zeke Morris
  Ld Vcl / Gtr Hr Vcl / Bjo Hr Vcl / Dobro Bs      
  Melvin Goins
Ray Goins
Harley Gabbard
Dave Sutherland
 
   
A-3
Pistol Packin' Mama
01:52
10 May 1970
Bluegrass Country

Al Dexter
  Ld Vcl / Gtr Hr Vcl / Bjo Hr Vcl / Dobro Bs      
  Melvin Goins
Ray Goins
Harley Gabbard
Dave Sutherland
 
   
A-4
Lonesome Pine
03:22
10 May 1970
Bluegrass Country

Curly Ray Cline / Mike Paxton
  Ld Vcl / Gtr Hr Vcl / Bjo Hr Vcl / Dobro Bs      
  Melvin Goins
Ray Goins
Harley Gabbard
Dave Sutherland
 
   
A-5
Windy Mountain
02:25
10 May 1970
Bluegrass Country

Curly Ray Cline
  Ld Vcl / Gtr Hr Vcl / Bjo Hr Vcl / Dobro Bs      
  Melvin Goins
Ray Goins
Harley Gabbard
Dave Sutherland
 
   
A-6
Gone Home
01:58
10 May 1970
Bluegrass Country

Bill Carlisle
  Ld Vcl / Gtr Hr Vcl / Bjo Hr Vcl / Dobro Bs      
  Melvin Goins
Ray Goins
Harley Gabbard
Dave Sutherland
 
   
B-1
Chief Sitting Bull
01:52
10 May 1970
Bluegrass Country

Melvin Goins / Ray Goins
  Gtr Bjo Dobro Bs      
  Melvin Goins
Ray Goins
Harley Gabbard
Dave Sutherland
 
   
B-2
Fly Little Bluebird
03:46
10 May 1970
Bluegrass Country

Melvin Goins / Ray Goins / Mike Paxton
  Ld Vcl / Gtr Hr Vcl / Bjo Hr Vcl / Dobro Bs      
  Melvin Goins
Ray Goins
Harley Gabbard
Dave Sutherland
 
   
B-3
Wreck Of The Old '97
01:52
10 May 1970
Bluegrass Country

??
  Gtr Bjo Ld Vcl / Dobro Bs      
  Melvin Goins
Ray Goins
Harley Gabbard
Dave Sutherland
 
   
B-4
Why Do You Treat Me The Way That You Do?
02:25
10 May 1970
Bluegrass Country

Curly Ray Cline
  Ld Vcl / Gtr Hr Vcl / Bjo Hr Vcl / Dobro Bs      
  Melvin Goins
Ray Goins
Harley Gabbard
Dave Sutherland
 
   
B-5
White Lightning (reissue only)
03:04
10 May 1970
Bluegrass Country

George Jones (arr Dave Sutherland)
  Hr Vcl / Gtr Hr Vcl / Bjo Hr Vcl / Dobro Ld Vcl / Bs      
  Melvin Goins
Ray Goins
Harley Gabbard
Dave Sutherland
 
   
B-6
Daddy Sang Bass
02:11
10 May 1970
Bluegrass Country

Carl Perkins
  Hr Vcl / Gtr Hr Vcl / Bjo Ld Vcl / Dobro Bs      
  Melvin Goins
Ray Goins
Harley Gabbard
Dave Sutherland
 
   
Other artwork / related images:
Rear Cover Front Cover (reissue) Rear Cover (reissue)

For the Official Ralph Stanley II and the Clinch Mountain Boys site, visit:

Ralph II ralph2.com

Spotlight on:-

Smarter Than The Average Idiot
(Tin Ear TE-33010)


CME Recommends...

A Life Of Constant Sorrow
alifeofsorrow.com

CME Recommends...

Ralph Stanley Museum
ralphstanleymuseum.com

CME Recommends...

Hills Of Home Festival
drralphstanleyfestival.com

CME Recommends...

Rebel Records
rebelrecords.com

CME Recommends...

Bluegrass Unlimited
Bluegrass Unlimited